Author Archives | George Weigel

George Weigel - who has written 204 posts on Catholic Exchange.


Contact the author

The Hate Disease

Posted on 18 July 2008

A glimpse at what faces the next president of the United States can be gleaned from a speech by Dr. Attah Abu Al-Subh, culture minister of Hamas, which controls the legislative council of the Palestinian Authority. Speaking on Al-Aqsa TV…

The Name Game

Posted on 30 June 2008

In late April and early May, the blogosphere was in an uproar over two documents circulated by the National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC), which is charged with strategic coordination among federal agencies of the war against terrorism. “The Words That Work”…

The Presumptions of a Pastoral Letter

Posted on 20 June 2008

Twenty-five years ago, in early May 1983, the Catholic bishops of the United States approved what many imagined would be a historic public policy statement: The Challenge of Peace (TCOP). The debate during the drafting of TCOP was intense; the…

The Nobility of Cardinal Dulles

Posted on 12 June 2008

If the United States had a nobility, Avery Dulles would have been born into it. His great-grandfather, John W. Foster, and his great-uncle, Robert Lansing, both served as Secretary of State. So did his father, John Foster Dulles, who also…

Poland after John Paul II

Posted on 05 June 2008

When you add it all up, I’ve spent more than a year and a half of my life in Poland.

My Polish adventures began sixteen years ago, when I went to Warsaw, Cracow, and Gdansk in June 1991 to learn how…

Navy SEAL, “Martyr of Charity”?

Posted on 02 June 2008

Prior to Maximilian Kolbe’s canonization in 1982, there was considerable debate in higher Church circles about whether this Polish Franciscan, who had sacrificed his life in the starvation bunker at Auschwitz to save the condemned father of a family, should…

The Pope and the Universities

Posted on 22 May 2008

Benedict XVI had barely left the Catholic University of America on April 17 when the Catholic higher education establishment’s spin machine shifted into high gear. One university president said that what most impressed him about the papal address to Catholic…

A Papal Follow-up

Posted on 17 May 2008

Amidst some splendid Catholic theater, there were a lot of ideas to chew on in Benedict XVI’s visit to the United States. The pope’s sermon in St. Patrick’s Cathedral, in which he used the stained glass, the harmony, and the…

Going Against the Grain

Posted on 09 May 2008

“Political theology” is a controversial term, these days. In The Stillborn God, Columbia professor Mark Lilla argues that political theology is lethal for democracy, because democracy requires a public square scoured of religious reference points. Needless to say, I take…

Light from the East

Posted on 05 May 2008

One of the more jarring transitions in the liturgical year is the rapid switch from the beautiful pastoral exhortations of the First Letter of Peter, which the Office of Readings prescribes for Easter Week, to the high drama of the…

Architecture, Ideas, and Faith

Posted on 03 May 2008

In my Walter Mitty life, I’m not turning two with Cal Ripken at Camden Yards, or playing the Emperor Concerto with the National Symphony; I’m not even writing the Great American Novel. No, when I imagine a different life it’s…

A Pope of Historic Vision

Posted on 17 April 2008

John Paul II arrived in Warsaw on June 2, 1979; there and then, he ignited the revolution of conscience that would give birth to the Solidarity movement, the Revolution of 1989 and the end of European communism. Distinguished secular historians…

Remembering Bill Buckley

Posted on 14 April 2008

Who were the most publicly influential American Catholics of the twentieth century?

By shaping Vatican II's teaching on Church-and-state, Fr. John Courtney Murray, SJ, helped turn Catholicism into the world's foremost institutional advocate of religious freedom. John F. Kennedy put Catholics…

‘Gay Marriage’ and Father Keenan, Once Again

Posted on 10 April 2008

I regret having to revisit this matter, but as a point of personal honor has been raised, I must.

In early 2003, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts engaged in a vigorous public debate over the definition of marriage. A proposed constitutional…

The Ignatian Possibility Today

Posted on 01 April 2008

In the early 1990s, I was given lunch at the Roman headquarters of the Society of Jesus by two very — no, make that extremely — high-ranking Jesuits. The table-talk turned to a fascinating question: Are there permanent religious charisms in the Church? Most religious congregations die within a century of their founding; our Lord might delay his return for tens of thousands of years, so that we are the "early Church." Given that fact and that possibility, could we, today, judge that there are permanent religious charisms in the Church, gifts of the Holy Spirit that will endure institutionally in religious orders?

Easter vs. Irony

Posted on 26 March 2008

 At the beginning of Lent, I was sent a moving account of the recent funeral procession of a young American soldier, which took place near his hometown in the South. The most striking section read as follows:

"[T]he most incredible thing happened following the service on the way to the cemetery. We went to our cars and drove to the cemetery escorted by at least ten police cars with lights flashing…Everyone on the road who was not in the procession pulled over, got out of their cars, and stood silently and respectfully, some with their hands over their hearts.

“Global citizens” and U.S. Politics

Posted on 19 March 2008

A Canadian friend recently alerted me to an international petition being organized by Avaaz.org, a "community of global citizens who take action on the major issues facing the world today." (According to the organization's polyglots, "‘avaaz'…means ‘voice' or ‘song' in…Hindi,…

The West and the Rest

Posted on 13 March 2008

In his book, Without Roots, Pope Benedict XVI deplored the addiction to historical self-deprecation rampant at the higher altitudes of European cultural and intellectual life: a tendency to see in the history of the West only "the despicable and the destructive." The same problem exists on this side of the Atlantic; in our universities and among our cultural taste-makers, the healthy western habit of moral, cultural, and political self-critique can dissipate into forms of self-loathing. Perhaps a civilization can afford to think of its past as pathology when it has no competitors. That is manifestly not the case today, when the West is being challenged by radical Islamist jihadism and by the new and market-improved authoritarianism of China.

Questions for Father General

Posted on 27 February 2008

Last month, the 35th General Congregation of the Society of Jesus elected Father Adolfo Nicolas, a Spaniard, as General of the order. A few days later, Father Nicolas gently chided Roman journalists for running some "not so helpful" stories about…

Lourdes and the Modern World

Posted on 19 February 2008

One hundred fifty years ago, on Feb. 11, 1858, an illiterate, impoverished 14-year-old girl received the first of 18 visions of Mary, who eventually revealed herself to Bernadette Soubirous as "the Immaculate Conception." In mid-19th century Europe, Lourdes, a small…

The Holy See and Islam: The Diplomatic Dance Continues

Posted on 04 February 2008

While the diplomatic maneuvering between the Holy See and Muslim leaders has taken several striking turns in recent weeks, the Vatican's strategic purpose in this conversation has been clear since Pope Benedict XVI's 2006 Christmas address to the Roman Curia.…

Anonymity and Remembrance in Berlin

Posted on 30 January 2008

I'd not been in Berlin since 1987 - before the Wall came tumbling down — so I eagerly accepted an invitation to speak at an international conference there this past November. The change is dramatic. Where the dreaded "Vopos" or…

An Islamic Leo XIII?

Posted on 16 January 2008

There's been a lot of chatter since 9/11 about Islam's need for a Martin Luther, a Muslim reformer who would accelerate this great world religion's acceptance of two key planks in the platform of political modernity: that religious freedom is…

Cardinal Kasper on the State of Ecumenism

Posted on 09 January 2008

2008 marks the one hundredth anniversary of the Chair of Unity Octave, which has evolved into an annual pan-Christian week of prayer running from January 18-25. Prayer, it seems, is what is most required in the early 21st century quest for…

The God With an Infant’s Face

Posted on 25 December 2007

As my too-cute-to-be-true grandson, Master William Joseph Susil, careened around the house over Thanksgiving, exercising his rapidly expanding vocabulary and wreaking havoc on unsecured objects in his path, I couldn't help but imagine possible futures for him.

The guy who breaks…

Books for Christmas

Posted on 17 December 2007

A year ago, the formidable Dorothy Rabinowitz asked me for a Christmastide Wall Street Journal column, to be dubbed the "Five Best Books on Christianity." I suggested Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, and Acts; Dorothy demurred. So I simmered down and gave…

Among the Fallen

Posted on 08 December 2007

Judged by the standards of a century replete with political slaughter, the Spanish Civil War of 1936-39 can seem a relatively tame affair. Tens of millions died in Stalin's Ukrainian hunger famine, the Holocaust, Mao's Great Leap Forward, and Pol…

Civility, Charity, and Truth-telling

Posted on 30 November 2007

Thoughtful Americans across the spectrum of political opinion are rightly concerned about the degree to which our national politics has degenerated into the manipulation of consumer desires and passions, often by the seductions of the electronic media. That those manipulations…

The Global Good News

Posted on 24 November 2007

Doomsday-mongering is a staple feature of the faux-intellectual life, occasionally influential and sometimes quite lucrative. The Club of Rome's dire certainties about the "limits to growth" shaped Carter Administration thinking and policy. Paul Ehrlich's tediously repetitious predictions that "over-population" would…

Don’t Play Down Differences in the Name of Unity

Posted on 23 November 2007

Some have suggested that the removal of the Rev. Ray Martin as pastor of several parishes in South Baltimore — for offenses that included officiating at a funeral Mass with an Episcopal priest — indicates a lack of commitment to…

China’s One-Child Self-Destruction

Posted on 15 November 2007

A real piece of work: back in the day, that's what we'd have called my friend Nicholas Eberstadt. By his own confession, Nick left Harvard a convinced Maoist — only to find, during his early graduate work at the London…

A Disappointing Call for Dialogue

Posted on 09 November 2007

On October 11, at the end of Islam's holy month of Ramadan, 138 Muslims from around the world addressed a letter to Pope Benedict XVI and numerous other Christian leaders. Entitled "A Common Word Between Us and You," the letter…

Camelot Revisited

Posted on 05 November 2007

John F. Kennedy would now be 90 years old — a circumstance virtually impossible to imagine, for those of us alive on November 22, 1963. When Lee Harvey Oswald's bullets killed the 35th president of the United States, our memories…

Poland after John Paul II

Posted on 18 October 2007

 When you add it all up, I've spent more than a year and a half of my life in Poland.

My Polish adventures began 16 years ago, when I went to Warsaw, Cracow and Gdansk in June 1991 to learn…

Please Pass the Ontology

Posted on 04 October 2007

A philosophically-minded young friend recently sent me a fine rant, after having watched a presidential candidates' cattle call on CNN. The discussion had focused on religion.

Several candidates, who identified themselves as Catholics, had indicated that their Christianity was rather…

What We Can’t Not Know, Six Years after 9/11

Posted on 25 September 2007

Six years after 9/11, there are certain things we can't not know. We may wish these things weren't true. We can try to ignore them. But safe passage through a moment in history fraught with both danger and possibility requires…

Cardinal Lustiger, R.I.P.

Posted on 13 September 2007

Visitors to the Cathedral of Notre-Dame in Paris will soon be able to ponder a commemorative marker carrying this inscription:

I was born Jewish. I received the name of my paternal grandfather, Aaron. Having become Christian by faith and by baptism,…

The Ripken Ethic

Posted on 30 August 2007

In Men at Work, George F. Will began his celebration of baseball defense with a tale of Cal and Bill Ripken turning a rally-killing double-play while their father watched from the visitors' dugout in Toronto — and concluded with an…

Chairman Gioia Makes NEA Work

Posted on 20 August 2007

Tradition tells us that baseball is the national pastime. Economics tells us that it's pro football. Casual conversation makes it clear that the America's favorite sport is complaining about government. Herewith, then, something counterintuitive: an encomium to government, indeed to…

Lord, Please Don’t Hear This Prayer: A Reprise

Posted on 07 August 2007

A while back, I noted with a touch of asperity that the "Prayer of the Faithful" too frequently deteriorates into serial sermonettes, an AmChurch innovation without foundation in the Church's liturgical tradition. I was particularly scornful of petitions that politicize…

California Dreamin’, Missin’ the Real Deal

Posted on 31 July 2007

Ah, the summer of 1967. A gangly young Australian priest named George Pell turned up at my Baltimore parish and became a family friend; none of us imagined him the Cardinal Archbishop of Sydney four decades hence, but there it…

The Case for “Moral Democratic Realism”

Posted on 26 July 2007

In The Joys of Yiddish, the late, great Leo Rosten noted with relish the classic definition of chutzpa: "Chutzpa is that quality enshrined in a man who, having killed his father and his mother, throws himself on the mercy of the…

The Coming Crisis in Episcopal Demographics

Posted on 24 July 2007

As of June 1, 2007, the diocese of Birmingham had been without a bishop for two years, while the diocese of Pittsburgh (not to mention the entire state of Arkansas) had been bishop-less for over a year. Without significant change,…

Martyrdom and the Christian Future in Iraq

Posted on 17 July 2007

In early June, I received a forwarded e-mail from a correspondent who's done several tours in Iraq. He, in turn, had just heard from an Iraqi fellow-Catholic, a former translator for U.S. forces there, of the death of Father Raheed…

Spin vs. Professionalism

Posted on 07 July 2007

The press was even more an unruly beast in 1787 than it is today; yet the Framers of the Constitution gave the fourth estate extraordinary latitude, convinced that the robust exchange of ideas was democracy's lifeblood. Journalism's virtual immunity from…

We Are Not Morons

Posted on 28 June 2007

Writing in the May 21 issue of America, Bishop Donald W. Trautman of Erie, chairman of the U.S. bishops' Committee on the Liturgy, called the lay people of the Church to the barricades, urging us to "speak up!" in response to…

Land O’Lakes Forty Years Later

Posted on 05 June 2007

Forty years ago this coming summer, some two dozen prominent Catholic educators met at a Wisconsin resort and issued the "Land O'Lakes Statement." Those were heady days in the academy: the Council of "openness," Vatican II, had ended eighteen months…

The Pope on Abortion, Politicians and Communion

Posted on 29 May 2007

Flying to Brazil on May 9, Pope Benedict XVI was asked whether he supported the excommunication of Mexican legislators who had voted to legalize abortion. The Pope replied, "Yes, this excommunication was not something arbitrary, but is foreseen by the…

Clinical Notes: Gonzalez v. Carhart

Posted on 25 May 2007

The day after the Supreme Court upheld the federal partial birth abortion ban by a 5-4 vote, the pseudonymous "Diogenes" offered a rather chilling commentary on the Catholic World News Web site:

"In her angry dissent in Gonzalez v. Carhart, (Justice)…

Catholic Challenges in Latin America

Posted on 21 May 2007

With Pope Benedict XVI heading for Brazil in mid-May to open the fifth general meeting of CELAM, the pan-continental conference of Latin American bishops, the focus of international Catholic attention will rightly turn to one-half the world's Catholic population, its…

CE Spotlight