Patrick and the Homeless Woman: A Ride on a Cablecar

October 16th, 2007 by Alice Gunther ·Print ·

After an evening of sightseeing in downtown San Francisco, my husband suggested I take a few of the older children to ride home on a cablecar. Our young tourists were only too happy with this prospect, waving goodbye to Daddy and their three-year-old sister, who were assigned to meet us at home with the van. 

Just as the children settled down to their seats in the indoor cabin, a graying homeless woman hobbled on, looking confusedly left and right. The older girls instinctively made room for her, and she fell into the bench between five-year-old Patrick and his sisters with a thud.

She was already in mid-conversation before even hitting the seat, telling me immediately that she was a Vietnam Veteran. "It's Fourth of July, and I'm a Vietnam Veteran," she insisted, "but nobody cares. It don't matter to them." The row of passengers across from us fell as silent as a radio unplugged, all eyes soberly fixed out windows and in books. "I am clean," she continued loudly to me — or to no one in particular, "I am a Vietnam Vet'ran."

With that, Patrick, who was paying no attention to her exclamations, jumped up to get a better view. He bounded past the woman and seemed bent on reaching the outdoor cabin. "Patrick," I called to him urgently, sit down — you could fall out!"

The woman turned in her seat to glare at me, as if I had been interrupting. "Nobody ever listens to me!" she shouted. "Nobody cares! Nobody listens!" "Oh, excuse me," I said, weakly, "I was listening, but I was afraid my little boy would…" "Nobody ever listens!" she cut me off, pulling a white hood over her head so that it almost covered her eyes and leaning forward to rock back and forth. "You are going to push me over the edge, you and all the rest of you! You don't care! Nobody cares!" The passengers opposite kept their eyes trained out windows and in books, the natural human response when closed in with an erratic person.

Rattled by her display, Patrick cuddled up a bit closer to me, so that there was room for a person to sit between himself and the woman. A wave of passengers clambered in at a stop. "Look at them all!" she sobbed, still rocking. "I guarantee not one of these people will be willing to sit down next to me! I'm clean, but not one of them will sit here! Not one of them will sit next to me!" With that, Patrick, who had been clinging to me, relaxed a bit, inching ever so slightly toward her. He gingerly pushed my shawl into the empty place as if trying to fill up the seat.

She noticed the shawl out of the corner of her eye and stopped rocking. "You are trying to fill up that seat, aren't you young man?" He did not answer but looked back at me. She continued, her face and tone suddenly serene, "You don't want me to be alone, do you?" The entire cablecar held its breath, and a few eyes even peeped up from books. "Thank you," she murmured, "thank you young man, for showing me some love." He did not look away, but listened, unblinking.

 "Young man," she continued, her poor withered face wreathed in smiles, "you showed a woman named Roxanne some love tonight and gave her hope. You are a fine young man, and do you know why you are such a fine young man?" Speaking now for the first time, Patrick softly whispered, "Why?"

"Because," she said, "you have a good mother, a mother who teaches you not to look down on anyone." Hearing her response, Patrick turned his head back to me, and from the depths of his innocent little heart he said, "I love you, Mom," planting a kiss on my cheek. Several "awwwws" from the other passengers were audible, and Roxanne beamed approvingly as the cablecar ground to a halt. "Thank you, young man, thank you!" she repeated, rising and stepping toward the exit. The girls called after her, "Happy Fourth of July," as merrily as if she was packing to leave a picnic, and she replied in kind, "Happy Fourth of July!" knocking on the glass behind us for a few more waves. As the cable car rumbled on, we could see her staggering from the street to the curb, almost too impaired to make the step.

Although I felt a measure of relief to roll away in safety with the children, two quotes from the Bible began playing in my head, repeating themselves as insistently as the rhythm of Roxanne's rocking:

"Foxes have dens and birds of the sky have nests, but the Son of Man has nowhere to rest his head." (Matthew 8:20)

"'Amen, I say to you, whatever you did for one of these least brothers of mine, you did for me.'" (Matthew 25:40)

Our Lord not only did not look away from people like Roxanne. He sought them out as companions and friends, living among them and asking us to treat them with mercy and love.

Our trip completed, we set out for home still chattering about the night's excitement. In the distance, a tall man carrying a toddler wrapped in a long pink poncho was walking toward us, the steep terrain no hindrance to his steady, quick step.

And the children sprang up the hill to meet their father.

Alice Gunther is an attorney and homeschooling mother of seven. She can be found online at alice.typepad.com/cottage_blessings.


4 Comments For This Post

  1. Guest says:

    What a beautiful story.

  2. Guest says:

    wow

  3. Guest says:

    I was in San Francisco several years ago for a trade show.  Going out to dinner one evening, a bunch of us got off one of those same cable cars and were immediately met by a wave of pan handlers.  All of my companions brusquely walked past, hurriedly.  I stopped and gave one of the men a dollar.  He immediately asked me, "You're not from around here, are you?" I replied that no, I wasn't and asked him how he knew.  "Most people give only a few coins; or walk right past; but you gave me a dollar.  Thank you." It was only a dollar; not a lot; but it was what I had in my pocket at the time; and he was grateful.  Later, one of my co-workers asked me why I had bothered.  I told him that you never know when you're going to meet an angel.  They come to you in the most unlikely circumstances.

  4. Guest says:

    I worked in the financial district of San Francisco for years. The homeless people were everywhere. On and off of Bart on all the street corners, at the hotel and restaurant sidewalks, begging for food or money. I had compassion for them too, I saw their suffering and the mental and physical anguish, I saw it day after day, week after week, year after year, many times it was the same homeless person for all those years. I always carried money to give them but my true concern was not for their momentary needs but for their long term needs, no one was doing anything about that. Most, and I would say 80% of the homeless I came in contact with from day to day had mental disorders that most likely could be helped with proper medication, others had drug or alcohol problems and that was my concern in giving money… sometimes at lunch I would buy a take out sack and give it to someone… it was always appreciated. We can do what we can do as individuals but noone was helping the homeless in any really constructive way (except private organizations like the Salvation Army who are not helped by the City of San Francisco who will not give them any funds because, on ethical principal, the Salvation Army will not provide their employees with gay or unmarried partners health insurance). The homeless are complained about, pushed aside or given the "crumbs" from the table of thriving municipalities and that is the true evil.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

CE Spotlight